Defying Recession Signals: Stock Market Rally Gains Momentum

Stocks have continued their upward trajectory as the stock market rally gains momentum, defying initial recession signals and prompting Wall Street to reconsider its economic forecasts. However, some investors remain cautious and are not ready to declare the all-clear just yet. Their concerns stem from various factors, including ominous economic signals, elevated equity valuations, and uncertainty surrounding the Federal Reserve’s interest rate policies.

Despite expectations of lackluster corporate earnings in 2023, the S&P 500 has surged 19% this year, showcasing remarkable resilience. Yet, the worry lingers as analysts remain watchful of potential headwinds that could challenge this growth trajectory.

Mike Mullaney, director of global markets research at Boston Partners, points out the current vulnerability in equities, emphasizing that any negative developments could have significant repercussions.

Get WSJ Print Edition Subscription 1 Year 6-days a week delivery

The focus has shifted to the actions of the Federal Reserve, with investors anticipating a quarter percentage point increase in interest rates. But their attention lies primarily on the central bank’s future plans, particularly whether it intends to continue raising rates beyond the immediate hike.

Not too long ago, inflation concerns and the Fed’s stringent measures to combat it painted a bleak picture for both the markets and the economy. Deutsche Bank research highlights that significant U.S. disinflation episodes in the past, driven by Fed tightening, have invariably led to recessions, which, in turn, have negatively impacted stocks.

Last year, the stock market’s performance seemed to validate such concerns, with the S&P 500 experiencing a 25% drop from its January 2022 high to its October low. However, contrary to expectations, stocks made a robust comeback at the beginning of 2023. The S&P 500 emerged from its longest bear market since the 1940s and surged 27% from its lowest point, hovering near its pre-pandemic highs in April 2022.

The Economist and Barrons Digital Subscription for $129

The recent cooling of inflation and the sustained momentum of the economy have bolstered investor confidence. A robust jobs market and increased retail spending have further fueled economic optimism. Some market experts, like Dryden Pence, chief investment officer at Pence Capital Management, express optimism that the Federal Reserve may handle the situation adeptly.

Despite these positive signs, there are lingering concerns. The Conference Board’s leading economic index has experienced 15 consecutive months of decline, signaling potential slowing economic activity ahead. Additionally, the bond market’s inverted yield curve, with longer-term U.S. Treasury yields falling below shorter-term ones, hints at potential economic challenges.

Wall Street Journal 2-Year Print Subscription Take 70% Off

The market for bank loans has also shown signs of weakening, with lending standards tightening for households and businesses, and lower demand from borrowers. Such conditions can hinder economic growth as investment and hiring decrease, and consumers have less disposable income.

Hans Olsen, chief investment officer at Fiduciary Trust, remains perplexed by the ongoing stock market rally gains in the face of these warning signs. His firm has taken a cautious approach, selling U.S. stocks in April and increasing cash holdings to safeguard against a possible market downturn.

The New York Times and Barron’s News 3-Year Digital Subscription Combo

The stock market’s valuations are notably elevated relative to historical levels, raising concerns among investors. The S&P 500’s price-to-earnings ratio has risen to 19.6 times projected earnings for the next 12 months, surpassing the 10-year average, leaving the market susceptible to potential corrections.

Furthermore, though inflation has moderated, it remains above the Federal Reserve’s target of 2%. There’s a possibility that the central bank may decide to raise rates again later in the year or maintain higher rates for an extended period, leading to unpredictable consequences for the economy and the markets.

In conclusion, while the stock market rally has remained strong despite recession signals and some positive economic indicators, investors remain vigilant about potential risks and uncertainties, emphasizing the need for caution and prudent investment strategies moving forward.